Saturday, April 9, 2016

12. INDONESIA: ITS LANGUAGES, PEOPLE, AND RELIGIONS



12. INDONESIA: ITS LANGUAGES, PEOPLE, AND RELIGIONS
 Indonesia is an archipelago. Its official motto is Bhinneka Tunggal Ika in Old Javanese "Unity in Diversity.”   It is written on the scroll gripped by the Garuda's claws, a mythical bird and the mount of Lord Vishnu. As an archipelago it was said in 1972 that the number of islands in Indonesia was 6.127, but in 1987 the number increased to 17.508, but only 5.707 had names. In 1992, the number of islands having names increased to 6.489. In 2002, the number of islands increased to 18.306. In 2004 the Department of Interior recorded that there were 7.870 islands with names, and 9.634 without names. (The total: 17.504 islands). Only about 6.000 islands are inhabited, and the remaining over eleven-thousand islands are uninhabited. 
          In 2010 it was estimated that the number of tribes in Indonesia was 1.340. In Papua (formerly called “Irian Jaya”) there are 466 tribes. The biggest tribe is the Javanese living in Central and Eastern Java. It consists of about 41% of the total of population. No wonder that most of its presidents were Javanese:  Out of seven presidents until now, only B.J. Habibie was from outside Java. The next big tribe is Sundanese, consisting of 15.4 % of the total population living in West Java. Chinese Indonesians are 3.7%, Malays are 3.4%, Madurese 3.3 % and Arab Indonesians, 2.4%. In fifteen years of research it was found that there are more than 746 tribal languages in these 17.508 islands of Indonesia. Its 240 million people belong to almost 500 ethnic groups with their own cultural traditions, languages and dialects.
  Since their independence in 1945, the Malay language has been adopted as the official language of Indonesia, called “Bahasa Indonesia” (Indonesian language). It is always taught alongside the native language in all schools. However, long before this, in 1928 the Indonesian Jong Islamieten Bond (Islamic Youth Association) delegates in Youth Pledge in Batavia (now Jakarta) had made their pledge unanimously that Indonesia had one nation, one homeland and one national language, the Indonesian language. Most of the Indonesians are bi-lingual, their mother-tongues and their national language, Indonesian.
 The Indonesian language has adopted many loanwords from other languages, such as Sanskrit, Arabic, Persian, Portuguese, Dutch, and Chinese, Austronesians, and recently, English.  Sanskrit loanwords came either directly from India, or through the Old Javanese language. They cover many aspects of religion, because before the advent of Islam in Indonesia, its people were either Hindus or Buddhists, where Sanskrit words were used, such as: agama   (āgama, religion, sacred teaching),  angka (aṅka, numerical figure),  bahasa (bhāṣā, language), bahaya (bhaya, danger), bakti (bhakti, homage, devotion, service etc.), bumi (bhūmi,     earth), dana (dāna, donation, funds), kata (kathā, word, speech talk,  story), keluarga (kula-varga, family), kepala (kapāla, head),  madu (madhu, honey; in Indonesian also: co-wife), nama (nāma,  name), neraka (naraka, hell), rahasia (rahasya, secret), raja (raja, king), samudra (samudra, ocean), suara (svara, sound), and surga (svarga, heaven). All these words are no longer considered foreign words.
With the conversion of the Indonesians into Islam, many Arabic words were introduced, especially dealing with worship and devotion. Among the examples are as follows: adab, ajaib, akal, akhir, akhirat, alam, aman, asal, badan, berkat, daftar, izin, kamus, kitab, kursi, sabar, sabun, sedekah, sehat, unsur, umum, umur. Sometimes the adoption changes the meaning. For example, the word ralat is taken from ghala (غَلَط) meaning “mistake, error”, but in Indonesian it means correction of mistakes.”  Another example is the word “fitnah” which means in Arabic: “temptation, trial; charm, enchantment; riot, discord, and civil strife,” like we are having now in the Middle East. But in Indonesian it means “slandering, and defamation,” resulting with misinterpreting the Qur’ānic verse  ... وَالْفِتْنَةُ أَشَدُّ مِنَ الْقَتْلِ....  (البقرة:191)  and fitnah (polytheism) is worse than killing.” (Q. 2:191), and. وَالْفِتْنَةُ أَكْبَرُ مِنَ الْقَتْلِ ... (البقرة:217) “and fitnah (polytheism) is worse than killing…(Q. 2:217).[1] Slandering and defamation never means in Arabic fitnah, but rather qadhf (قَذْف) and iftirā’ .(إفْتِرَاء)
 An idolater was mistakenly killed by the Muslims. Qur’ān commentators say that the meaning of fitnah in this verse is “polytheism, idolatry” which is the gravest sin. Although killing is a grave sin, the sin of the killed idolater is graver, as there is no forgiveness for idolatry. Allah says:
إِنَّ اللَّهَ لَا يَغْفِرُ أَنْ يُشْرَكَ بِهِ وَيَغْفِرُ مَا دُونَ ذَلِكَ
لِمَنْ يَشَاءُ... (النساء:116,48)
 setting up partners (in worship) with Him,
but He forgives whom He wills,… (Q. 4:48, 116)
Another example of adopted Arabic word which changes the meaning is the word “masyarakat”, originally from the word ­mushārakah (مُشَارَكَة) which means “partnership, cooperation, participation,” but in Indonesian language it means “community, society” which is in Arabic mujtama (مُجْتَمَع)  meaning “community, society, commune, assembly, gathering place”
A new word is being introduced into Indonesian to address a person we respect, instead of “engkau” for singular or “kamu” for plural (but is also used for singular), which is used only by elders for the young and children in general. It is the word “anda” which is derived from the Arabic anta meaning “you” in respect. It is used like the term Sie rather than du in German, and Lei rather than tu in Italian. But apparently its use is not very common. However, it is also said that it is adopted from Nias language.
Among words adopted from Persians are: anggur (an-gur,  grape), bandar (port), cadar (chādar, veil), pahlawan (pahlwān, hero), pasar (bāzār, market, bazaar),  nakhoda (nākhodā, captain of a ship), piala (pyāla, cup, trophy) and takhta (takht, throne). From Chinese we adopt bakmie (bak mie, meat noodle), bakso (bak so, meatball), cap cai (cha̍p-chhài, lit. “mixed vegetable”, stir fried vegetable dish),  cukong (cu kong, tycoon), gua (gua/wa, me , slang ), kecap (Keng Cio, soybean sauce). (ketchup is 'saus tomat', tomato sauce, not kecap), kue (kwe,  cake, pastries), lumpia (lun pia, spring roll), mi/mie (mie, noodle), tahu (toufu/tauhu, tofu), and teh  (te, tea).
Although the Portuguese did not occupy Indonesia, many words were adopted into Indonesian, such as: meja (mesa,   table), boneka ( boneca, doll), jendela (janela, window), gereja  (igreja, church), bola (bola, ball), bendera (bandeira, flag), roda (roda, wheel), sepatu (sapato, shoe), kereta (carreta, wagon), bangku (banco, chair), keju (queijo = cheese), garpu (garfo, fork), terigu (trigo = flour), mentega (manteiga, butter), and Minggu (domingo, Sunday). 
There are about 10,000 Dutch words adopted into Indonesian, including the names of the months, from January to December, such as: polisi (politie, police), kualitas (kwaliteit, quality), wortel (wortel, carrot), kamar (kamer, room, chamber), rokok (roken, to smoke, smoking cigarettes), korupsi (corruptive, corruption), persneling (versnelling, gear), kantor
 (kantoor, office),   kelas (klas = class), and gratis (gratis, free), om/paman (oom, uncle), oma/nenek (oma, grandma),         struktur (structuur, structure), teori (theorie, theory), karcis (kaartje, ticket), apotek (apotheek¸ farmacy).
          Among local languages modern Javanese has contributed the most to the Indonesian language due to their vast majority of if its native speaker among the population (41%), such as: adem (adhem, cool temperature), ambruk (collapse), apik (neat, nice), ayu (beautiful, pretty, gorgeous, graceful, elegant), edan (edhan, crazy), ganteng (ngganteng, handsome), and  pemirsa (viewers). From Sundanese language we have: getol (active), lalap (lalab, raw vegetable, consumed), majikan (boss),  risih (uneasy, uncomfortable), pengaruh (pangaruh, influence), and pemulung (waste picker). From Minangkabau which is said to have been a precursor or old dialect of Malay language we have: galau (confusion), gengsi (prestige), rendang (randang, rendang), usang (obsolete). From Betawi language, spoken by people who used to live in Betawi (now Jakarta) we have: butut (old fashioned), gelandangan (homeless), mampus (dead). From Nias we have anda (you, respectful), from Batak we have molek (voluptuous), from Maluku we have beta (I, me, myself) and from Manado we have pasti (so pasti, sure).
Malay-Indonesian language is one of the easiest languages in the world without harsh sound, nor complicated grammar. For example, the work makan (eat) remains without declension or case, so that it does not change whoever, and whenever one says it. The word akan (shall, will), sudah (already) are used before the verb to indicate the future and the past respectively.
Indonesia is the most successful multicultural and multiracial country. It recognizes six official religions. According to 2010 census: 87.18 % are Muslims (more than 99% Sunnis, 0.5 % Shias, and 0.5% Ahmadis), 6.96% Protestant (Protestantism was introduced by the Dutch, concentrated in Maluku, North Sulawesi, Nusa Tenggara, Kalimantan, and Papua), 2.91% Catholic, (Catholicism was brought by the Portuguese, notably to the island of Flores), the 1.69% Hindu especially in Bali (Bali-Hindu), 0.72% Buddhist, 0.05% Confucianism, 0.13% other, and 0.38% unstated.  Later, Christianity was also brought to Torajas in Central Sulawesi and the Batak people, predominantly Protestant.
There are two major Muslim organisations in Indonesia: Nahdatul Ulama (NU), is the largest “traditionalists” one claiming more than 50 million members, probably the largest Islamic organization in the world. It was founded by Kyai Hasyim Asy’ari in 1926. It advocates religious moderation and communal harmony. Its activities are in social and religious education and operating Islamic boarding schools (pesantren). It adheres to the ideology and teachings of Ahlus Sunnah wal Jama’ah, and the Shafi’i school.  Its presence is strong in rural Java. Former President, the late Abdurrahman Wahid was the grand-son of the founder.
The other major Muslim organization is Muhammadiyah, founded by Kyai Haji Ahmad Dahlan in 1912. Its orientation is “modernists” and adheres to orthodox theology, but embraces modern learning. When the late Dr. Hamka, the prolific writer an one of the prominent leaders and scholars of Muhamadiyah was asked what madhdhab (school of jurisprudence) he was following, he answered, “Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi’i, and Hanbali schools.” It is the leading national “modernist” organization, has approximately 29 million members, and has branches throughout the country. It runs mosques, prayer houses, clinics, orphanages, poorhouses, schools, public libraries, and universities, such as Muhammadiyah universities in almost every big city, such as, Jakarta, Yogyakarta, Surakarta, Malang and Makassar.
Indonesia as the largest Muslim populations in the world is a battle-ground for proselytization between Christian missionaries and Muslim propagators. The missionaries seemed to get upper hand, especially in poor areas, such as Papua and Central Java, since they receive massive foreign funds from abroad, such Australia, USA, Germany, Vatican, and Italy. On the contrary, Muslim propagators succeeded in bringing people to Islam through dialogue, especially priests and clergymen    who, after conversion, became Muslim propagators, such as Dr. Yahya Waloni and Bernard Nababan and Fadhlan Grammatan.
          Since the Islamic revolution in Iran in 1979 many Indonesian Muslims have become attracted to the Twelver-Shi’a of Iran. Many students went to Iran to study the Shi’a there. In Indonesia many schools are built for Shi’a children. Dialogues and debates are common phenomena. Even in the Muslim world, especially in the Midd East, the debate between scholars of the two sects, the Sunni and the Shi’i, can be watched in the YouTube of the internet. The debates became often hot when one party was asked questions which cannot be answered with “yes” or “no”. For example, Shaykh Adnan Aroor (عدنان العرعور) asked: “Is the decision of al-Ḥasan to make peace agreement and to abdicate the imāmah (leadership) to Mu‘āwiyah right or wrong?” If the opponent said “yes”, then his younger brother al-Ḥusayn should also have done the same to Yazīd, and he was wrong for not doing so. If the opponent said “no”, then how could al-Ḥasan the second imām have committed a mistake, when as an imam he was supposed to be ma‘ṣūm (infallible)? The only escape for the opponent was that he claimed that it was not the topic of the debate.
          As the influence of the Shiah in the Muslim world in general and in Indonesia in particular keeps on increasing, Allah sends His selective servant as rescue. His name is Shaykh Husayn al-Muayyad (حسين المؤيد). He obtained the highest position in Iraq as a scholar, and was entitled “the greatest ayatollah(آية الله العظمى). After “converting” to Sunnah, he took refuge to Saudi Arabia, leaving everything behind: his family and relatives, friends and colleagues, and his country. He was not the first “ayatollah” who turned to be Sunni, but most probably the first one who was successful leaving his country.
           Shaykh al-Mu’ayyad has given in Ṣafā satellite channel (قَنَاةُ صَفَا) 74 series of lectures and 64 series in Wiṣāl (قناة وصال) in the internet, and answers questions. Although his lectures are in Arabic, some are provided with Indonesian translation. He says that if the Shiah followers believe only in what has been clearly mentioned in the Qur’ān , such as praying and fasting in Ramadan, they would have abandon the Shiah, as the teachings of the Shiah are not clearly based on the Qur’ān , such as the imāmah, wilāyah, and ‘iṣmah (infallibility) of the imams, etc.  For his website please visit  www.almoaiyad.com.
          It is not an exaggeration to say that the ink of the scholar is worthier than the blood of the martyr.  Why? The blood kills the enemy, but the ink does not kill the enemy; it kills his enmity and turns the enemy into ally. Suppose five against five! If you kill one, the balance becomes 5 against 4; but if you kill his enmity, the balance becomes 6 against 4. That is wisdom: no blood spilled, no woman turned into a widow, and no child turned into an orphan. That was the Prophet did: he turned the general of his enemy into his own general: Khālid ibn al-Walīd.
                                                          (Turner, 9 April, 2016)
المراجع:
المكتبة الشاملة
تفسير الطبري (ت. 310 هـ(
تفسير القرطبى (ت. 671 هـ(  
http://www.10winds.com/50languages/did_you_know/EN071.HTM
https://asian.washington.edu/fields/indonesian https://id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daftar_pulau_di_Indonesia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhinneka_Tunggal_Ika
http://www.asianinfo.org/asianinfo/indonesia/pro-languages.htm  




[1]قال أبو جعفر: يعني تعالى ذكره بقوله:"والفتنة أشد من القتل"، والشرك بالله أشدُّ من القتل (الطبري). أَيْ شِرْكِهِمْ بِاللَّهِ وَكُفْرِهِمْ بِهِ أَعْظَمُ جُرْمًا وَأَشَدُّ مِنَ الْقَتْلِ الَّذِي عَيَّرُوكُمْ بِهِ (القرطبي) .

Friday, April 8, 2016

11. WHY ARE YOU MUSLIM?

11. WHY ARE YOU MUSLIM?
Why am I Muslim? Why do I convert to Islam? The real answer is that it is Allah’s guidance. He says:
...وَاللَّهُ يَهْدِي مَنْ يَشَاءُ إِلَى صِرَاطٍ مُسْتَقِيمٍ (االبقرة:213; النور:46)
And Allah guides whom He will to a Straight Path.
(Q. 2:213; 24:47)
          While the Muslims in Indonesia were being invaded with Christian missionaries with massive foreign aids, when they were desperately in need of rescue, apparently, Allah “stepped in” with His “divine intervention” through the conversion of some Christian scholars, clergymen and priests into Islam, such as, Dr. Yahya (formerly Yopie) Waloni, Petrus Kali who changed his name into Ahmad Fikri after his conversion and turned his church into a mosque, Bernard Nababan, and the  former nun Irene Handono (see Khutab IV, no. 6 and 9).
 One of the amazing conversions to Islam was that of Emmanuel Manoppo, the only son of the Head of the Indonesian Council of Churches, who converted to Islam in 1990. His father expected him to take his place one day, but Allah had another plan. One night he dreamed a man with a white robe told him to convert to Islam to gain salvation. When he asked the identity of the man, he said that the Muslims knew him, as he used to come in a special night of the year. He found out that it was in the “Night of Power” (Laylat al-Qadr) and the person was the angel Gabriel (Jibrīl). Out of frustration his father persuaded him then punished him and hit him hard, but to no avail. His heart had become solid and unshakable (See Khutab III, no. 24).
The well-known pop star Cat Stephens when he was admitted to the hospital for contracted TB, he started thinking, was he just a body, and his goal in life was merely to satisfy his body, why was he in the hospital’s bed? When he was walking and was caught in the rain, getting wet made him think that the body is like a donkey, and has to be trained where it has to go, or it will lead you where it wants to go. He started to be interested in Eastern religion and became vegetarian. He was not interested in Buddhism because he was not ready to leave the world, to become a monk and to isolate himself from society. He tried Zen, Ching, numerology, tarot cards and astrology.
One day Cat Stephens’ brother after returning from the mosque in Jerusalem handed him a copy of the Holy Qur’an. About one and a half years later in 1977 he converted to Islam and changed his name to Yusuf Islam. He then could get direct contact with God, Allah. He was told that the Hindus also believe in one God, but the objects (idols) are used merely to concentrate. Therefore, in order to reach God in Hinduism one has to create associates, namely, idols.
 When the Muslim scholar Dr. Abū Shādī was asked this question: “Why are you Muslim?” he gave a comprehensive answer as follows:
  1.     Islam which I believe is a simple and merciful faith compatible with reasonable logic; it is based on confirming the Oneness of God Who invented this creation and disposes its affairs on wise ancient and general rules. There is no description of Him holier and purer than that in Islam. Verily, the description of divine glory in this religion combines the concept of established scientific reality and the objects of educational and spiritual philosophy.
  2.  Islam rejects association with Allah in all of its manifestation, and objects all efforts to make His Oneness obscure through associating Him with any other than Him. Islam definitely considers idolatry humiliation to reason and degradation to humanity. Man in Islam is a master and free from various elements of nature. He is neither a slave of the universe nor one who subjects the existence. Instead, he is a being with extreme ability to choose, has free will, and is part of the divine order in this wide world.
  3.  Islam is integrated with revealed religions that preceded it. The teachings of ‘Īsā (Jesus) a.s., especially in peace and blessing, are defended and supported more extensively in Islam. The Jews and the Christians living in Muslim countries are treated as Muslims in nationality, even if they keep their own beliefs. As Islam does not allow conversion by forces, it treats them like its followers, based on the rule: “For them what is for us, and on them what is on us.”
  4. Islam is against aggression and corruption, as from the beginning it has called for freedom and justice, and opposes oppression and wrong-doing.
  5.    Islam is a universal religion, cannot be limited to a special environment, class (nation) or with race. It is an established human reality.
  6.  Islam has a flexible constitution in its laws and moral behavior which is the Qur’ān. As the Qur’ān is based on general precepts for belief and moral behavior the Muslims are left freely to make rules suitable for their areas and eras based on common interests and acceptable ijtihād (independent judgment, especially in a legal question based upon the interpretation of the Qur’ān and the Sunnah).
  7.     Islam considers knowledge the lightening lamp guiding to the interpretation of its signs and showing the truth of its message. Therefore, it wages war against ignorance and foolishness, and honours learning and wisdom. 
  8.  Islam does not acknowledge any mediator between man and his Lord. Therefore, there is no priesthood in Islam in any form. It respects human personality, and believes in the possibility of its elevation when it follows the guidance of its firah (natural disposition) and the call to the faith.
  9.   Islam based on its teachings in social justice and true democracy, establishes its own political regulation for governing and remains the source of enormous blessings among people as long as it is fully applied. This governing will not fall down until it abandons its teaching and leads itself to self-destruction. 
  10.   Islam is a practical religion guaranteeing both physical and spiritual success. It completely purifies itself from superstitions, idle talks, foolish occults, and delusive imagination created by blind discrimination
  11.    Islam considers the position of knowledge higher than that of formal worships, as knowledge in its essence is a kind of devotion through which the truth upon which faith is based will be revealed, and with it superstition will vanish.
  12.   The Qur’ān mentions all kinds of predictions applicable with human development in discoveries and inventions which have never been imagined by anybody since fourteen centuries. If the Qur’ān were revealed today, not a single letter would change, as its validity for all eras would not be questioned
  13. The Bible and the Torah have made prediction on the advent of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. with his message, which is beyond interpretation, despite the arguments of scholars of Christianity and Judaism on its meanings.
  14. The origins of Islam come from reason and natural disposition, and therefore it is open to accept all systems in conformity with its exalted moral principles, which will guarantee the welfare of human beings wherever they are. Therefore, it supports, maintains, and protects all high civilizations, so that its philosophy contains them. They develop and give share in creating prosperity to Muslims in particular and to human beings in general.
  15. Islam does not tolerate reactions at all. Instead, its constant motto is progress and development. Any confinement against freedom and revival is tantamount to denying it.  Every person’s right is respected, especially the freedom of thinking and speech, and they have to defend Islam, although they do not follow it.
  16. Man himself is considered responsible for his own salvation by doing good deeds, and there is no mediation, intercession or redemption to save him if his deeds do not save him. The concept of redemption is unknown to Islam.
  17.  Muslim can be a follower of Moses, Jesus and Muhammad at the same time, because this is the spirit of Islam and its internationality. Moreover, Islam was, and is still, and will remain capable of leading the world in true democratic way based on the spirit of love and peace.
Dr. Abū Shādī states further that because of these distinguished reasons and various secondary reasons he prefers  to remain Muslim and to be proud of his belief in Islam, leaving broad interpretation and practical application of it for  concerned experts and helping cultured and conscious scholars concerned with this noble deed.
  People with clear and clean heart will see the truth of Islam and will follow it. Knowing the truth does not guarantee that one would follow it. Iblīs knows the truth, but he rejects it out of envy and arrogance. Therefore, we keep praying,
اللهم أرنا الحقّ حقّا، وارزقنا اتّباعه، وأرنا الباطل باطلًا، وارزقنا اجتنابه
O Allah show us the truth as truth, and bless
 us with following it, and show us falsehood
as falsehood, and bless us with avoiding it.
                                        (CIVIC, 8 April, 2016)
المراجع:
محمد الغزالي. كَيْفَ نَفْهَمُ الإسْلام؟ القاهرة: نهضة مصر, 2005
Baagil, H.M, M.D. Muslim-Christian Dialogue. Jeddah: Abul-Qasim Publishing House, n.d.
15/07/05/ nqzhzp-pendeta-masuk-islam-gereja-diubah-menjadi-masjid


[1]God addressed Moses indicating the advent of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. as follows: “I will raise them up a Prophet from among their brethren, like unto thee (Moses), and will put my words in his mouth; and he shall speak unto them all that I shall command him.”   (Deuteronomy 18:18). (1)  Among their brethren”, namely, brethren of Israelites (descendants of Abraham through Isaac, including Jesus), are the Ishmaelite (descendants of Abraham through Ishmael, including   Muhammad s.a.w.).  (2) “Like unto thee (Moses): Birth: usual for both (Moses and Muhammad), unusual for Jesus. Family life: both were married and had children, whereas Jesus without marriage or children.  Death: natural for both, unnatural for Jesus. Career: both were prophets and statesmen, whereas Jesus was a prophet only. Forced emigration in adulthood: Moses to Median, Muhammad to Madinah, whereas Jesus did not emigrate in adulthood. Encounter with enemies: Moses: hot pursuit; Muhammad: hot pursuits and battles; Jesus: no similar encounter. Results of encounter: Both: moral and physical victory; Jesus: moral victory only. Writing down of revelation: Both in their life times (Moses: Torah; Muhammad: al-Qur’an); Jesus: after him. Nature of teachings: Both: spiritual and legal; Jesus: mainly spiritual. Acceptance of leadership by his people: Both: rejected then accepted; Jesus: rejected by most Israelites. (3) “Put my words in his mouth.”  This is in line with the Qur’anic verse: وَمَا يَنْطِقُ عَنِ الْهَوَى. إِنْ هُوَ إِلَّا وَحْيٌ يُوحَى (النجم:3-4) “Nor does he speak of (his own) desire. It is only a Revelation revealed.” (Q. 53:3-4). “And it shall come to pass that whosoever will not hearken unto my words which he shall speak in my name, I will require it of him.” (Deuteronomy 18:19). This verse is in line with the Qur’anic verse: وَلَوْ تَقَوَّلَ عَلَيْنَا بَعْضَ الْأَقَاوِيلِ.لَأَخَذْنَا مِنْهُ بِالْيَمِينِ.ثُمَّ لَقَطَعْنَا مِنْهُ الْوَتِينَ (الحاقة:44-46)  If he (Muhammad) had forged a false saying concerning Us (Allah), We surely would have seized him by his right hand (or with power and might), and then We certainly would have cut off his life artery (aorta)” (Q. 69:44-46). Both the late Ahmad Deedat, and his successor Dr. Zakir Naik mentioned in their speech that the expected Paraclete (Comforter, Counselor, Advocate, Helper) is no one but Prophet Muhammad s.a.w.